Reducing critical effects of torsional vibrations induced by PDC bits during rock destruction

Introduction. Torsional vibrations caused by drilling using a polycrystalline diamond compact (PDC) bit are analysed using wellbore data obtained under various drilling modes. The drilling caused by torsional vibrations are analysed. Two types of torsional vibrations, including those caused by the cutting action of a bit and by frictional forces.
Aim. To investigate the induction of torsional vibrations as a result of rock destruction by PDC bits.
Materials and methods. The research methodology was based on “Richard-Germay-Detournay” and “Tian-Detournay” bit designs and methods for reducing the critical effects of torsional vibrations induced by PDC bits during rock destruction.
Results. Statistical analysis has shown that the drilling efficiency of the bit (DE) correlates well with the occurrence of torsion vibrations caused by the bit. The aggressiveness of the cutting structure of the PDC bit can be represented by an average DE rating. If the PDC bit is designed so that its DE exceeds a critical value, then the occurrence of torsion vibrations on the bit is unlikely during drilling.
Conclusion. When drilling with a polycrystalline diamond PCD bit, two types of vibrations occur. If torsional vibration occurs due to the cutting action of the bit, then the fight against this process is focused on the design of the bit and operational parameters, the load on the bit and the speed of rotation of the bit. If the torsional vibration is caused by friction, vibration reduction methods should be focused on changing the design of the BHA and the drill string or the profile of the well. Therefore, it is very important to determine whether the torsional vibration is caused by the friction force of the elements, the cutting action of the bit, or both. In drilling, it is always necessary to search for the maximum penetration speed by changing the load on the bit under specified drilling conditions. To do this, it is necessary to evaluate the drilling efficiency of the DE bit, therefore, this article has evaluated the parameter depending on the size of the bit, which will determine the critical value of the drilling efficiency parameter.

1. Alimova M.M., Mashkova A.M., Solov’ev N.V. et al. Analysis of the nature of differential seizures and methods of their effective prevention // Young — Earth Sciences: Proceedings of the IX International Scientific Conference of Young Scientists. In 7 vol. Moscow, 31.03.2022. Moscow: Russian State University for geological Prospecting, 2022. P. 172—176.

2. Borisov K.A., Tret’yak A.A., Sidorova E.V. Effect of vibrations on the strength properties of PDC-reinforced drill bits // Exploration and subsurface protection. 2019. No. 12. P. 33—37.

3. Meshkov,S.V., Tret’yak A.A., Sidorova E.V. On the issue of reducing the friction coefficient when drilling wells // Young — Earth Sciences: Proceedings of the IX International Scientific Conference of Young Scientists. In 7 vol. Moscow, 23.10.2020. Moscow: Russian State University for geological Prospecting, 2020. P. 231—233.

4. SHihbabaeva E.G., Solov’ev N.V., Mashkova A.M. et al. MGRI inclinometer — Vibrations while drilling // Young — Earth Sciences: Proceedings of the IX International Scientific Conference of Young Scientists. In 7 vol. Moscow, 31.03.2022. Moscow: Russian State University for geological Prospecting, 2022. P. 300—304.

5. Bailey J.R., Payette G. S., Wang L. Improved Methods to Understand and Mitigate Stick-Slip Torsional Vibrations //IADC/SPE Drilling Conference and Exhibition. — OnePetro, 2018.

6. Chen S., Grosz G., Anderle S., et al. The Role of Rock-Chip Removals and Cutting-Area Shapes in Polycrystalline-Diamond-Compact-Bit Design Optimization // SPE Drill & Compl. 2015. No.30(40). P. 334—347.

7. Chen S., Khlefat Y., Cleboski C., et al. A New Method of Backup-Cutter Layout To Extend Bit Life without Sacrificing Rate of Penetration // SPE Drill & Compl. 2018. No. 33(2). P. 115—129.

8. Dao N.H., Menand S., Isbell M. Mitigating and understanding stick-slip in unconventional wells // SPE/IADC International Drilling Conference and Exhibition. — OnePetro, 2019.

9. Detournay E., Richard T., Shepherd M. Drilling Response of Drag Bits: Theory and Experiment // Int J Rock Mech Mining Sci. 2008. No. 45(8). P. 1347—1360.

10. Jain J.R. et al. Mitigation of torsional stick-slip vibrations in oil well drilling through PDC bit design: putting theories to the test //SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition. — OnePetro, 2011.

11. Jain J.R., Ricks G., Baxter B., et al. A Step Change in Drill-Bit Technology with Self-Adjusting Polycrystalline-Diamond-Compact Bits // SPE Drill & Compl. 2016. No. 31(4). P. 286—294.

12. Ledgerwood L.W., Jain J.R., Hoffmann O.J., et al. Downhole Measurement and Monitoring Lead to an Enhanced Understanding of Drilling Vibrations and Polycrystalline Diamond Compact Bit Damage // SPE Drill & Compl. 2013. No. 28(3). P. 254—262.

13. Macpherson J. D. et al. A Framework for Transparency in Drilling Mechanics and Dynamics Measurements // SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition. — OnePetro, 2015.

14. Richard T., Germay C., Detournay E. Self-Excited Stick-Slip Oscillations of Drill Bits // C R Me´canique. 2004. No. 332(8). P. 619—626.

15. Richard T., Germay C., Detournay E. A Simplified Model To Explore the Root Cause of Stick-Slip Vibrations in Drilling Systems with Drag Bits // J Sound Vib. 2007. No. 305(3). P. 432—456.

16. Schwefe T. et al. Development and testing of stick/slip-resistant PDC bits //IADC/SPE Drilling Conference and Exhibition. — OnePetro, 2014.

17. Shen Y. et al. The origin and mechanism of severe stick-slip //SPE annual technical conference and exhibition. — OnePetro, 2017.

18. Sugiura J., Jones S. A Drill Bit and a Drilling Motor with Embedded High-Frequency (1600 Hz) Drilling Dynamics Sensors Provide New Insights into Challenging Downhole Drilling Conditions // SPE Drill & Compl. 2019. No. 34(3). P. 223—247.

19. Wilson J.K., Whitacre T., Heisig G. High-Frequency AtBit Measurements Provide New Insights into Torsional Dynamics when Drilling with Steerable Mud Motors in Unconventional Horizontal Wells // SPE Drill & Compl. 2019. No. 34(4). P. 414—425.